No and no. Despite the menace and inconvenience of the band's sound for the unprepared listener, SOiL's retrospective work is in no way similar to the brutal chants of their overly active colleagues from, say, Pantera, whom Ryan and his band tried to copy at the dawn of their career.
Modern metal from SOiL is a loud’n’(quite) brutal music with a human face and just active life position — and based on the rock tradition of the past, too. The best illustration of this is the only new number from the CD's tracklist, a cover version of well-known standard Gimme Some Lovin' by The Spencer Davis Group (1967).
Almost mainstream female backing vocals combined here with Adam Zadel's brutal guitars, Ryan's aggressive roar, and the pounding-tight rhythm section led by SOiL co-founder, bassist Tim King teamed up with various drummers throughout the years (T.J. Taylor since 2017), and the sum is much better than its parts. Well, beyond this piece Scream: The Essentials loses its appeal to mainstream listeners. But no one argues that this CD is almost a purely niche product, designed for fans of SOiL, or modern metal (whatever it means) in general.
It is not intended to introduce a dumbfounded and unprepared listener to quite old and limitedly fashionable substyle — well, we’re not living in the 90s now. That is why the collection is compiled canonically: out of 19 “old” tracks, seven are pure rarities. They could be called bonuses, if they did not fit so perfectly into the overall sound of SOiL and into the concept of an angry ideological message on behalf of the band's musicians.
Perhaps, one new track and seven “old new ones” will not be enough for the fans of the band. But since Scream: The Essentials is designed for a not invisibly small audience, then it’s possible to be happy about it.
The label did everything for you, and you’re relieved of the need to search for SOiL best numbers on separate studio albums. It’s an undeniably reasonable approach for such an aggressive substyle.
1. Gimme Some Lovin' 3:18 (Scream: The Essentials, 2017) 2. Broken Wings 4:18 (Soil, EP 1997) 3. Road to Ruin 2:42 (Throttle Junkies, 1999) 4. Black Betty 2:41 (Throttle Junkies, 1999) 5. Halo 3:19 (Scars, 2001) 6. Unreal 3:18 (Scars, 2001) 7. Breaking Me Down 2:37 (Scars, 2001) 8. Pride 2:47 (Redefine, 2004) 9. Redefine 3:38 2:37 (Redefine, 2004) 10. Can You Heal Me (Acoustic Version) 3:43 (Redefine, 2004) 11. Give It Up 3:04 (True Self, 2006) 12. Let Go 3:52 (True Self, 2006) 13. Like It Is (Alternate Version) 3:34 (Picture Perfect, 2009) 14. The Lesser Man 3:43 (Picture Perfect, 2009) 15. My Time (Kickstart Version) (Whole, 2013) 16. Shine On 3:27 (Whole, 2013) 17. The Hate Song 3:15 (Whole, 2013) 18. Way Gone 3:35 (Whole, 2013) 19. Halo (Live in London) 4:52 (Re-LIVE-ing the Scars: In London, 2012) 20. Rusty Cage 4:27 (Bonus Track. Recorded in 2007) 21. Gimme Some Lovin' (Alternate Version) 2:51 (Scream: The Essentials, 2017) 1. Gimme Some Lovin' 3:18 (Scream: The Essentials, 2017) 2. Broken Wings 4:18 (Soil, EP 1997) 3. Road to Ruin 2:42 (Throttle Junkies, 1999) 4. Black Betty 2:41 (Throttle Junkies, 1999) 5. Halo 3:19 (Scars, 2001) 6. Unreal 3:18 (Scars, 2001) 7. Breaking Me Down 2:37 (Scars, 2001) 8. Pride 2:47 (Redefine, 2004) 9. Redefine 3:38 2:37 (Redefine, 2004) 10. Can You Heal Me (Acoustic Version) 3:43 (Redefine, 2004) 11. Give It Up 3:04 (True Self, 2006) 7. Never Kneel Down (Rise Above, 2023) 8. Raise Your Head (Alive, 2016) 9. To Be With You (Freedom Has No Price*, 2010) 10. Get Away (Alive, 2016) 11. Rise Above (Rise Above, 2023) 12. End of Days (Rise Above, 2023)SOiL. Scream: The Essentials Track List
SOiL at the ReLoad Fest in Sulingen, Germany on August 16th 2024.
Note from the editor
By the time of the publication of this review on September 22, 2024, SOiL completed two major tours. In March they toured with The Union Underground over the US with the program Back To The 2000’s. In August, they hit the road across Atlantics for the large European tour with Images Of Eden, which included shows at Wacken Open Air Fest in Germany, Brutal Assault Fest in the Czech Republic, a show in Cologne with Butcher Babies. and ReLoad Fest in Germany, concluding the tour on August 16.
During these tours, SOiL performed hit tracks such as “Halo,” “Unreal,” and “Breaking Me Down,” from their breakthrough album Scars, which are featured on Scream: The Essentials compilation reviewed here.
SOiL continues their 2024 touring spree in November by landing in the UK with The Union Underground, (Hed)PE, and Nonpoint.
Read more about SOiL 2024 tours on our special feature:
https://suleyera.com/music-life/rock-prog-metal/soil-tours-2024.html
This album review for Scream: The Essentials was originally written by Rick Patterfierld in 2017 at the time of the album release and has never been published. After joining a collaborative team of writers at Suley Era, Rick generously provided us with this review for publication.
Ryan McCombs - Vocals Tim King - Bass Adam Zadel - Guitar TJ Taylor - Drums
https://www.bandsintown.com/a/1358SOiL is:
Follow SOiL